1
00:00:58,154 --> 00:01:01,634
When he's talking, look at him.

2
00:01:02,434 --> 00:01:05,074
Okay. Speak.

3
00:02:21,394 --> 00:02:23,794
The secret recordings
are one of the biggest

4
00:02:23,874 --> 00:02:27,674
intelligence operations
of the Second World War.

5
00:02:30,954 --> 00:02:36,554
Using around a thousand personnel,
listening in to the conversations,

6
00:02:36,634 --> 00:02:39,754
the unguarded conversations
of German prisoners of war

7
00:02:39,834 --> 00:02:41,914
and even Hitler's generals.

8
00:02:46,514 --> 00:02:51,354
Even in the most far fetched science
fiction scenario that I can imagine,

9
00:02:51,434 --> 00:02:55,354
there will never be a scenario like
the one the British intelligence

10
00:02:55,434 --> 00:02:58,554
encountered during World
War II. On the one hand,

11
00:02:58,634 --> 00:03:02,674
you have a German prisoner of war
sitting and speaking to his friend,

12
00:03:02,794 --> 00:03:05,834
confessing about
war crimes he committed.

13
00:03:06,074 --> 00:03:10,954
And on the other hand, a British
soldier is listening, recording

14
00:03:11,034 --> 00:03:16,394
and transcribing. That British
soldier is actually a Jewish refugee

15
00:03:16,474 --> 00:03:20,594
from Germany who was listening to
what was happening to his own family.

16
00:03:22,354 --> 00:03:26,674
It is practically
impossible to find perpetrators

17
00:03:26,754 --> 00:03:31,834
of any atrocity where
they will speak honestly

18
00:03:31,914 --> 00:03:36,994
with regard to what happened and
with regard to their feelings

19
00:03:37,074 --> 00:03:39,874
and their explanations
about what happened.

20
00:03:40,194 --> 00:03:45,354
What you get with this
recording is real time statements.

21
00:03:47,994 --> 00:03:53,914
This operation was so top secret,
hush hush, even into the Cold War,

22
00:03:53,994 --> 00:03:57,514
that historians knew
nothing about these files

23
00:03:57,594 --> 00:04:00,354
until the end of the Cold War.

24
00:04:01,434 --> 00:04:04,514
There is nothing like this in
the research of World War II,

25
00:04:05,074 --> 00:04:07,754
where the story of the Holocaust

26
00:04:08,114 --> 00:04:10,874
is being told by the Nazis themselves,

27
00:04:11,314 --> 00:04:15,354
without any filters, and
most importantly, in real time.

28
00:04:17,314 --> 00:04:20,954
The transcripts of the recordings
reveal more than anything,

29
00:04:21,034 --> 00:04:24,074
the scale, the method, and the soul

30
00:04:24,154 --> 00:04:26,034
of those who perpetrated
the Holocaust.

31
00:05:08,434 --> 00:05:12,154
My father, Erich Mark,
once said to me,

32
00:05:12,634 --> 00:05:16,594
"There are two things that
you have to work at every day

33
00:05:16,674 --> 00:05:18,794
"and you must never take for granted.

34
00:05:19,394 --> 00:05:22,114
"One is democracy and
the other is marriage."

35
00:05:23,514 --> 00:05:28,354
What he meant by democracy is
that we each have to be conscious

36
00:05:28,434 --> 00:05:30,554
of what democracy means.

37
00:05:33,314 --> 00:05:36,994
He was aware, as all
German Jews were in the '30s,

38
00:05:37,074 --> 00:05:39,674
that Hitler was elected
democratically.

39
00:05:41,354 --> 00:05:44,154
And he was elected democratically
because many people were

40
00:05:44,234 --> 00:05:46,914
just tired of all the changes

41
00:05:46,994 --> 00:05:50,234
of government and they just said,
fine, whatever it is, let it be.

42
00:05:51,154 --> 00:05:55,274
And that is the time when democracy is
in danger, is when people

43
00:05:55,354 --> 00:05:56,794
no longer take an interest

44
00:05:56,874 --> 00:06:00,074
in working at it and
thinking for themselves

45
00:06:00,154 --> 00:06:01,674
and thinking of their future.

46
00:06:08,354 --> 00:06:13,434
My father was one of 110
Jewish secret listeners,

47
00:06:14,514 --> 00:06:18,354
and as it turns out, he was
the last surviving secret listener.

48
00:06:19,754 --> 00:06:23,634
These were people who sat in
the basement where captured

49
00:06:23,714 --> 00:06:25,794
enemy officers were housed

50
00:06:25,874 --> 00:06:29,274
in such a way that they would
chat to each other in order to

51
00:06:29,354 --> 00:06:33,034
release secrets, which they
didn't realize were being bugged.

52
00:06:40,754 --> 00:06:46,114
For about 70 years, my
father did not speak of this.

53
00:06:46,594 --> 00:06:49,594
He had signed the Official
Secrets Act, and that is a

54
00:06:49,674 --> 00:06:50,794
closed and locked door.

55
00:06:55,314 --> 00:06:59,594
The British devised a plan to
listen to every prisoner of war

56
00:06:59,674 --> 00:07:02,274
who passed through
certain detention sites,

57
00:07:03,514 --> 00:07:07,194
and these sites would be wired with
microphones in every corner that

58
00:07:07,274 --> 00:07:08,274
you can think of.

59
00:07:08,354 --> 00:07:12,874
In labs, under the pool table,
in the fireplace, essentially the

60
00:07:12,954 --> 00:07:17,114
whole place was wired with
undetectable microphones.

61
00:07:18,234 --> 00:07:23,514
The goal was that those POWs
could leave without understanding

62
00:07:23,594 --> 00:07:25,394
that all their conversations

63
00:07:25,474 --> 00:07:26,794
are being recorded and then

64
00:07:26,874 --> 00:07:28,954
transcribed by the
British intelligence.

65
00:07:32,394 --> 00:07:35,754
This was an operation
unprecedented in its scale.

66
00:07:36,314 --> 00:07:40,234
Almost 10,000 soldiers passed
through those detention sites.

67
00:07:40,874 --> 00:07:44,594
The British allocated almost
unlimited funds for this operation.

68
00:07:48,474 --> 00:07:52,474
The prisoners didn't realize we
were listening in to them and so

69
00:07:52,554 --> 00:07:54,434
they were very relaxed and

70
00:07:54,514 --> 00:07:58,714
we gained some of the highest
secrets of the Nazi regime.

71
00:07:58,794 --> 00:07:59,874
It was incredible.

72
00:08:00,554 --> 00:08:07,314
And it would amass over 75,000
transcripts of conversations.

73
00:08:07,634 --> 00:08:12,714
It was a huge industrial
scale intelligence operation.

74
00:08:15,514 --> 00:08:18,914
They were released into the
National Archives in London

75
00:08:18,994 --> 00:08:22,114
between the late
1990s and early 2000s.

76
00:08:22,474 --> 00:08:27,474
It took over five years for
someone in the UK Ministry of Defence

77
00:08:27,874 --> 00:08:29,874
to actually look at these files

78
00:08:29,954 --> 00:08:32,314
to check that there was
nothing still sensitive in them.

79
00:08:34,114 --> 00:08:35,994
During our research for this series,

80
00:08:36,354 --> 00:08:38,754
we travelled to the
National Archives in London

81
00:08:38,834 --> 00:08:41,194
and we've extracted
all the source material

82
00:08:41,474 --> 00:08:45,514
that involves the Holocaust,
war crimes and anti Semitism.

83
00:08:47,114 --> 00:08:49,394
Essentially, touching an open nerve

84
00:08:49,634 --> 00:08:52,794
that very few historians
have dealt with.

85
00:08:57,794 --> 00:09:00,794
The significant breakthrough
is that for the first time

86
00:09:00,994 --> 00:09:03,554
we have direct testimonies
of the Holocaust

87
00:09:04,034 --> 00:09:05,994
that no one has read or heard before.

88
00:10:22,514 --> 00:10:24,594
I had the privilege of
spending a long time in the

89
00:10:24,674 --> 00:10:29,354
National Archives in London, reviewing
those documents myself.

90
00:10:29,834 --> 00:10:32,874
For me, it was a
horrific, shocking revelation.

91
00:10:33,114 --> 00:10:36,634
I had never encountered
such raw materials like that.

92
00:10:40,074 --> 00:10:43,234
Their voices come to
life, but in complete apathy,

93
00:10:44,114 --> 00:10:48,194
showing little, if any,
regard to human lives.

94
00:10:48,874 --> 00:10:51,994
There are passages
when the transcriber

95
00:10:52,074 --> 00:10:53,434
writes in brackets, "Laughter."

96
00:10:54,874 --> 00:10:56,554
And I remember that it caught me.

97
00:10:57,634 --> 00:11:01,514
It was a very deep,
unsettling experience.

98
00:11:02,954 --> 00:11:04,474
And the sad truth is,

99
00:11:04,554 --> 00:11:08,074
the Allies knew about the
extent of the extermination,

100
00:11:08,354 --> 00:11:12,034
and they knew it as early as
1942, and they did nothing.

101
00:11:39,394 --> 00:11:41,794
I found it really shocking.

102
00:11:43,154 --> 00:11:46,194
These are actually
prisoners talking to each other

103
00:11:46,274 --> 00:11:49,074
about how the Nazi
killing machine worked,

104
00:11:49,434 --> 00:11:50,994
step by step.

105
00:11:53,474 --> 00:11:55,434
You remain changed forever.

106
00:11:55,674 --> 00:11:57,114
It's making me quite emotional.

107
00:11:58,474 --> 00:12:03,834
You can't erase those descriptions.

108
00:12:04,834 --> 00:12:06,874
They kind of become personal

109
00:12:06,954 --> 00:12:12,034
because the stories of how
individual Jews died

110
00:12:12,114 --> 00:12:13,514
at the hands of the Nazis.

111
00:12:13,594 --> 00:12:16,154
In a way, it's no longer a
huge figure, these are

112
00:12:16,234 --> 00:12:19,234
individuals and that touched me

113
00:12:19,314 --> 00:12:22,994
deeply that you can't
be unchanged after that.

114
00:13:01,274 --> 00:13:06,514
In 1933, Hitler comes to power
and he is extremely charismatic.

115
00:13:17,794 --> 00:13:22,034
He manages to form a government
that actually changes everything

116
00:13:22,114 --> 00:13:24,714
and makes Germany
into the Third Reich.

117
00:14:50,834 --> 00:14:53,514
Very quickly, he makes
those extreme ideas,

118
00:14:53,594 --> 00:14:54,874
something that you
can hear everywhere.

119
00:14:59,434 --> 00:15:04,834
And what Hitler does is he harnesses
this idea to make the case

120
00:15:04,914 --> 00:15:09,434
that the Jews are in fact
Germany's major enemy.

121
00:15:09,714 --> 00:15:15,354
And if they're not eliminated, that it
will in fact come back to Germany

122
00:15:15,434 --> 00:15:18,914
and Germany will be
weaker and stop to exist.

123
00:15:37,834 --> 00:15:43,114
The recordings offer us a
glimpse into the rooted anti Semitism

124
00:15:43,434 --> 00:15:45,434
in the mind of the German soldiers.

125
00:15:47,874 --> 00:15:52,674
We enter the mind, regardless if
it's a private or a field marshal,

126
00:15:52,874 --> 00:15:56,274
as he tells us his own
views about the Jews.

127
00:15:56,754 --> 00:15:58,554
This is one of the crucial findings

128
00:15:58,634 --> 00:16:00,114
that emerged from these recordings

129
00:16:00,554 --> 00:16:04,314
because we now understand
just how anti Semitism

130
00:16:05,074 --> 00:16:08,714
was embedded in their
personality and characters.

131
00:16:10,514 --> 00:16:13,754
A soldier or a general
captured at any given moment

132
00:16:14,394 --> 00:16:17,234
gives us his own experiences

133
00:16:17,554 --> 00:16:19,634
of what he encountered during the war.

134
00:16:19,954 --> 00:16:23,434
And these reflections
helps us to understand

135
00:16:23,754 --> 00:16:26,394
how the mass murder of Jews developed

136
00:16:26,474 --> 00:16:27,954
into a full scale genocide.

137
00:18:49,554 --> 00:18:52,674
When they make it a
biological imperative

138
00:18:53,194 --> 00:18:57,394
by discussing Jews as
parasites, or as plague,

139
00:18:57,474 --> 00:18:59,874
or as a dangerous bacillus,

140
00:18:59,954 --> 00:19:02,554
when you start to use
that type of rhetoric,

141
00:19:02,954 --> 00:19:05,434
it drives a certain way of thinking.

142
00:19:05,834 --> 00:19:07,754
How do you get rid of the plague?

143
00:19:07,834 --> 00:19:09,834
You have to exterminate it.

144
00:19:09,914 --> 00:19:11,834
You have to annihilate it, right?

145
00:19:52,274 --> 00:19:55,874
From the moment the Nazi Party
becomes the power leading the state,

146
00:19:55,954 --> 00:19:59,674
we can see antisemitic
expressions in many different places.

147
00:19:59,754 --> 00:20:03,114
And the peak is in
Nuremberg Laws in September 1935.

148
00:20:05,874 --> 00:20:08,354
The assault on the Jews
is a legal assault

149
00:20:08,434 --> 00:20:11,834
and very soon we can see Jews kicked
out of the civil service as well

150
00:20:11,914 --> 00:20:13,674
as from many other places.

151
00:20:24,834 --> 00:20:30,194
In January 1935, my grandmother
put my father on a train.

152
00:20:33,274 --> 00:20:36,194
My father came to this
station in London.

153
00:20:37,354 --> 00:20:41,234
He was alone, just twelve
and a half years old.

154
00:20:42,314 --> 00:20:44,754
He came from Germany
because he couldn't be

155
00:20:44,834 --> 00:20:46,474
educated anymore in Germany.

156
00:20:46,554 --> 00:20:49,194
He'd been thrown out
of his grammar school

157
00:20:49,274 --> 00:20:53,034
for being a Jew and he needed
an education somewhere.

158
00:20:53,754 --> 00:20:56,314
And this was the place
that would take him in.

159
00:21:01,994 --> 00:21:07,754
He arrived very late at night,
10pm, he said it was a very

160
00:21:07,834 --> 00:21:10,834
cold, wet, rainy January day

161
00:21:11,354 --> 00:21:14,434
on the 13th of January 1935.

162
00:21:16,114 --> 00:21:19,914
And he brought with him a
suitcase, a small suitcase,

163
00:21:19,994 --> 00:21:25,514
with just a few clothes
and his beloved Teddy, Hans,

164
00:21:26,514 --> 00:21:30,514
who is still in the family
and very precious to us.

165
00:21:37,914 --> 00:21:42,034
He couldn't know, he had no
idea what the future held for him.

166
00:21:44,354 --> 00:21:49,154
He certainly had no idea that
he'd end up as a secret listener

167
00:21:49,234 --> 00:21:51,354
for the British Intelligence Corps.

168
00:21:55,994 --> 00:22:00,994
On the night between November
9th and November 10th, 1938,

169
00:22:01,074 --> 00:22:03,594
something dramatic
happens in Nazi Germany.

170
00:22:11,074 --> 00:22:13,154
An organized attack starts.

171
00:22:14,794 --> 00:22:18,154
Synagogues are being burned,
businesses are being looted,

172
00:22:18,914 --> 00:22:20,714
people, Jews, are being killed,

173
00:22:20,794 --> 00:22:23,714
and tens of thousands are
being arrested the next day.

174
00:22:23,794 --> 00:22:25,514
And I'm talking
about the Kristallnacht,

175
00:22:25,594 --> 00:22:26,714
the Night of Broken Glass.

176
00:22:29,834 --> 00:22:32,434
This is the first
event in which we can see

177
00:22:32,954 --> 00:22:36,554
widespread violence within
the street of Nazi Germany,

178
00:22:36,634 --> 00:22:40,514
expressing the ideological
themes of the Nazi Party.

179
00:22:56,394 --> 00:23:01,594
September 1st, 1939, the
Second World War breaks out.

180
00:23:02,234 --> 00:23:05,834
Nazi Germany invades
Poland, and within a month,

181
00:23:05,914 --> 00:23:07,474
the Polish army collapses.

182
00:23:09,314 --> 00:23:12,314
France and Great Britain
declare war on Nazi Germany.

183
00:23:12,794 --> 00:23:16,474
But actually from that
moment, they do nothing

184
00:23:16,554 --> 00:23:18,674
until they themselves
will be attacked.

185
00:23:21,114 --> 00:23:24,354
The British didn't have to
wait long for German POWs.

186
00:23:25,274 --> 00:23:28,754
At least one German pilot escaped by
parachute while his blazing

187
00:23:28,834 --> 00:23:30,954
machine went hurtling down to earth.

188
00:23:31,234 --> 00:23:33,274
The pilot landed
safely and was captured.

189
00:23:37,114 --> 00:23:41,234
At the beginning of the war, most of
the prisoners were from the U boats.

190
00:23:41,554 --> 00:23:43,794
They'd been sunk in various campaigns

191
00:23:43,874 --> 00:23:46,034
and the survivors
pulled out of the water

192
00:23:46,274 --> 00:23:48,514
and they came to these secret sites.

193
00:23:48,834 --> 00:23:52,754
Then, of course, we started
to capture German Air Force,

194
00:23:52,834 --> 00:23:54,194
the pilots and the crew.

195
00:23:54,674 --> 00:23:58,114
But also, we don't often
think about those commando raids

196
00:23:58,194 --> 00:24:01,114
that were mounted into
Norway, into parts of France.

197
00:24:01,994 --> 00:24:05,314
British military
captured prisoners there

198
00:24:05,394 --> 00:24:07,354
and brought them back to secret sites

199
00:24:07,434 --> 00:24:09,514
and they gave up vital information.

200
00:24:10,754 --> 00:24:14,274
German prisoners of war
arrived at the Tower of London

201
00:24:14,354 --> 00:24:17,714
to what will become an
eavesdropping operation

202
00:24:17,794 --> 00:24:20,914
that will continue until
several months after the war.

203
00:24:25,074 --> 00:24:28,674
That iconic tourist
attraction today that we all love

204
00:24:28,754 --> 00:24:31,234
was actually the very first place

205
00:24:31,314 --> 00:24:35,834
where we held German prisoners
of war in the autumn of 1939.

206
00:24:36,274 --> 00:24:39,114
And already the special
engineers had been in,

207
00:24:39,194 --> 00:24:42,474
they had embedded microphones
in the light fittings,

208
00:24:42,554 --> 00:24:45,474
in the fireplaces, in
some of the towers.

209
00:24:49,314 --> 00:24:52,034
And the first German
prisoners started to arrive

210
00:24:52,114 --> 00:24:54,074
by the middle of September 1939.

211
00:24:58,154 --> 00:25:01,594
There's no roughing up of
prisoners, there's no brutality.

212
00:25:02,394 --> 00:25:04,994
They would have a sort
of phony interrogation.

213
00:25:06,514 --> 00:25:09,514
They'd go back to the
room where their mate was

214
00:25:09,594 --> 00:25:11,594
and they'd start to boast

215
00:25:11,674 --> 00:25:14,434
about what they hadn't told
the interrogating officer.

216
00:25:18,994 --> 00:25:21,634
And they also think that the British

217
00:25:21,714 --> 00:25:23,674
are stupid and incompetent.

218
00:25:23,754 --> 00:25:26,634
We know that because we heard
that through the microphones.

219
00:25:26,954 --> 00:25:28,914
Oh, the British, you know,

220
00:25:28,994 --> 00:25:32,114
they don't really know how to
conduct a proper interrogation.

221
00:25:33,714 --> 00:25:35,914
But the British
military intelligence officers

222
00:25:35,994 --> 00:25:38,274
knew exactly what they were doing.

223
00:25:38,354 --> 00:25:40,794
It was all part of this elaborate ploy

224
00:25:41,314 --> 00:25:43,474
to get those prisoners to speak

225
00:25:43,554 --> 00:25:44,994
to those hidden microphones.

226
00:25:49,714 --> 00:25:51,394
To conduct such an operation,

227
00:25:51,994 --> 00:25:53,874
you need a very particular figure.

228
00:25:59,514 --> 00:26:02,754
And the British had a
historical stroke of luck.

229
00:26:02,834 --> 00:26:04,554
They found Thomas Kendrick,

230
00:26:04,634 --> 00:26:08,914
an intelligence officer who was
not just an intelligence officer.

231
00:26:09,354 --> 00:26:13,674
He was a gentleman, an
officer, and a master spy.

232
00:26:16,434 --> 00:26:19,954
Thomas Joseph Kendrick is
one of my greatest heroes.

233
00:26:21,514 --> 00:26:26,274
He operated as one of
the leading spy masters

234
00:26:26,354 --> 00:26:31,834
for MI6 in Europe, out of
Vienna, in the 1920s and '30s.

235
00:26:31,914 --> 00:26:35,954
So he was undercover as the
British passport control officer.

236
00:26:36,274 --> 00:26:39,154
Of course, that was a cover
for his intelligence work,

237
00:26:39,514 --> 00:26:43,394
in which he ran spy networks
right across Eastern Europe,

238
00:26:43,474 --> 00:26:44,834
Czechoslovakia, Hungary,

239
00:26:45,074 --> 00:26:47,914
eventually into Italy
and into Nazi Germany.

240
00:26:52,794 --> 00:26:58,554
In March 1938, Adolf Hitler
did what he'd long intended

241
00:26:58,634 --> 00:27:00,874
to do, he annexed Austria

242
00:27:01,314 --> 00:27:03,554
in what became known as the Anschluss.

243
00:27:08,154 --> 00:27:09,994
From the moment
the Anschluss starts,

244
00:27:10,234 --> 00:27:12,554
the Jews of Austria find themselves

245
00:27:12,634 --> 00:27:15,074
in a situation unlike anything

246
00:27:15,154 --> 00:27:17,474
even the Jews of
Germany have faced yet.

247
00:27:20,394 --> 00:27:22,194
People are being
dragged to the street,

248
00:27:22,274 --> 00:27:23,754
forced to scrub the pavement.

249
00:27:25,074 --> 00:27:28,234
Children and old people are
humiliated in awful ways.

250
00:27:29,274 --> 00:27:32,514
As this is happening, Adolf
Eichmann comes to Vienna

251
00:27:32,594 --> 00:27:38,034
in order to organise the emigration
of Austrian Jews in an orderly way.

252
00:27:38,314 --> 00:27:42,114
In a few months, more than
50% of the Jews of Austria

253
00:27:42,194 --> 00:27:43,274
will leave the country.

254
00:27:46,354 --> 00:27:49,194
The following morning
after the Anschluss,

255
00:27:49,274 --> 00:27:52,234
Kendrick arrives at
the office to find the

256
00:27:52,314 --> 00:27:59,594
files say over 800 Jews
queuing, desperate to get out,

257
00:27:59,674 --> 00:28:02,274
and his staff make a conscious

258
00:28:02,354 --> 00:28:05,754
choice to embark on a
humanitarian mission.

259
00:28:09,554 --> 00:28:13,394
In the following months,
Kendrick and his staff issue

260
00:28:13,474 --> 00:28:17,834
thousands of visas, many of them

261
00:28:17,914 --> 00:28:20,954
false visas to get
Jews out of Austria.

262
00:28:24,394 --> 00:28:29,594
He becomes the Oskar Schindler
of Vienna and the official

263
00:28:29,674 --> 00:28:35,354
files tell us he saved
up to 200 Jews a day.

264
00:28:38,994 --> 00:28:43,554
Whilst this rescue effort's going
on, Kendrick himself is at great

265
00:28:43,634 --> 00:28:46,234
personal risk as the
Gestapo are on his tail.

266
00:28:46,674 --> 00:28:50,434
They're out to arrest
this elusive Englishman.

267
00:28:50,514 --> 00:28:54,634
They want to nab Britain's
top spy in Europe.

268
00:29:01,114 --> 00:29:04,514
Thomas Kendrick was arrested
in Vienna in August 1938.

269
00:29:06,514 --> 00:29:08,594
The British Foreign Office immediately

270
00:29:08,674 --> 00:29:11,034
intervened and he was
deported two days later.

271
00:29:14,034 --> 00:29:17,994
He then returns to London
and disappears from the public eye

272
00:29:18,074 --> 00:29:21,514
and that's when arguably one

273
00:29:21,594 --> 00:29:25,554
of his most important pieces
of work is about to begin.

274
00:29:30,154 --> 00:29:33,914
He knew how to organize large
groups under his supervision.

275
00:29:35,794 --> 00:29:39,354
Thomas Kendrick was the one
who took command over this unit

276
00:29:39,434 --> 00:29:42,474
whose job was to record and transcribe

277
00:29:42,554 --> 00:29:45,354
all the conversations of the POWs.

278
00:29:50,954 --> 00:29:53,314
In England, there are
already enough German prisoners

279
00:29:53,394 --> 00:29:54,634
of war to warrant this large

280
00:29:54,714 --> 00:29:56,394
and quite comfortable
looking prison camp.

281
00:29:56,914 --> 00:29:59,074
As a matter of fact, these
are U boat officers and men,

282
00:29:59,274 --> 00:30:01,994
and I should think they're
happier even behind barbed wire

283
00:30:02,074 --> 00:30:04,274
in a foreign land than
being hunted down at sea.

284
00:30:08,594 --> 00:30:10,834
It was a highly top secret section

285
00:30:10,914 --> 00:30:14,434
of the post office, the
post office research center,

286
00:30:14,754 --> 00:30:19,354
that actually sent in engineers
to wire the place for sound.

287
00:30:20,914 --> 00:30:24,034
This was the latest
state of the art technology

288
00:30:24,434 --> 00:30:26,354
that came from America.

289
00:30:26,594 --> 00:30:29,674
It was supplied by the
Radio Corporation of America.

290
00:30:30,274 --> 00:30:32,874
We needed this high level technology.

291
00:30:34,674 --> 00:30:37,754
The Germans clearly had no idea

292
00:30:38,314 --> 00:30:40,994
every single thing that
they did was captured.

293
00:30:42,074 --> 00:30:44,234
Somebody, just two feet or whatever,

294
00:30:45,074 --> 00:30:47,434
underneath them would be listening

295
00:30:47,514 --> 00:30:49,954
and notating and clocking everything.

296
00:30:51,514 --> 00:30:54,434
At the heart of all of
this were the M rooms.

297
00:30:54,754 --> 00:30:56,474
M stood for mic'd.

298
00:30:56,554 --> 00:30:58,714
And this is where the
secret listeners were.

299
00:32:02,194 --> 00:32:05,034
And they would record the
conversations onto

300
00:32:05,114 --> 00:32:08,034
78 inch acetate disks.

301
00:32:08,314 --> 00:32:11,954
So enormous disks, and
this huge technology

302
00:32:12,034 --> 00:32:14,794
that today looks
quite ridiculous to us,

303
00:32:14,874 --> 00:32:16,754
but it was latest state of the art.

304
00:32:18,274 --> 00:32:19,994
There was no time off.

305
00:32:20,074 --> 00:32:22,954
You had to monitor those conversations

306
00:32:23,474 --> 00:32:26,874
every single day of the
year, even on Christmas Day.

307
00:32:30,554 --> 00:32:33,514
And, of course, the conversations
were originally in German.

308
00:32:33,994 --> 00:32:36,594
So once the conversations
had finished,

309
00:32:36,674 --> 00:32:39,834
the secret listeners had to
listen to that conversation again

310
00:32:40,074 --> 00:32:44,274
and write with pencil
and paper, word for word,

311
00:32:44,834 --> 00:32:47,994
what that prisoner had said or
what they'd said to each other.

312
00:32:48,234 --> 00:32:50,714
And then, of course, it
had to be translated.

313
00:33:01,394 --> 00:33:04,874
And what survives today in
the National Archives are

314
00:33:04,954 --> 00:33:07,234
the typed up conversations

315
00:33:07,594 --> 00:33:11,274
in the original German and
in the English translation.

316
00:33:15,154 --> 00:33:18,674
So in contrast to today where
you can record hours of audio

317
00:33:18,754 --> 00:33:20,114
footage, often on a smartphone,

318
00:33:20,194 --> 00:33:23,794
back in the 1940s you were
using technology where the

319
00:33:23,874 --> 00:33:26,114
capacity allows you for seven minutes,

320
00:33:26,194 --> 00:33:29,874
you only have a finite number
of vinyls that you can use,

321
00:33:29,954 --> 00:33:31,994
and as a result you're
recording these,

322
00:33:32,074 --> 00:33:34,914
you're then listening back,
you're transcribing them,

323
00:33:34,994 --> 00:33:38,474
but then they're subsequently
wiped to reuse at a future date.

324
00:33:38,994 --> 00:33:42,674
So we lack the actual recordings
themselves, and in the end it

325
00:33:42,754 --> 00:33:45,954
means that the only details of
the conversations that we have are

326
00:33:46,034 --> 00:33:49,234
the transcripts that have been
declassified into government archives.

327
00:34:23,314 --> 00:34:26,994
And occasionally, as some of
the secret listeners told me,

328
00:34:27,354 --> 00:34:29,234
a particular prisoner might think,

329
00:34:29,314 --> 00:34:31,714
I wonder if they're listening
outside the door or something.

330
00:34:31,994 --> 00:34:33,874
So he would turn the tap on,

331
00:34:33,954 --> 00:34:35,434
there was a sink in their room,

332
00:34:35,514 --> 00:34:37,394
and they would talk very quietly.

333
00:34:38,194 --> 00:34:41,554
And those microphones
were so sophisticated,

334
00:34:41,634 --> 00:34:45,194
they could pick up that
conversation so clearly,

335
00:34:45,274 --> 00:34:48,154
even with the tap
running in their room.

336
00:34:53,394 --> 00:34:57,954
The first aim was, of course, to
find out military intelligence,

337
00:34:58,514 --> 00:35:02,154
information about weapons,
and then, through that,

338
00:35:02,434 --> 00:35:04,554
they found something very different.

339
00:35:05,114 --> 00:35:08,474
Suddenly, they realized that
they are actually recording

340
00:35:08,874 --> 00:35:11,034
the annihilation of the European Jews.

341
00:35:14,954 --> 00:35:17,234
From very early on in this operation,

342
00:35:17,594 --> 00:35:19,874
prisoners were
talking about atrocities,

343
00:35:19,954 --> 00:35:24,194
and they were even boasting
about the number of Jews that were

344
00:35:24,274 --> 00:35:25,954
being murdered across Europe.

345
00:36:02,354 --> 00:36:06,674
The British had a lot of categories
of information that they were after.

346
00:36:07,434 --> 00:36:11,834
Atrocities on the Eastern Front
was not one of those categories.

347
00:36:15,914 --> 00:36:18,954
From the moment Nazi
Germany invades Poland,

348
00:36:19,274 --> 00:36:23,314
the Jews of Poland find themselves
in a completely different situation

349
00:36:23,394 --> 00:36:25,714
and this starts from
the very first hours.

350
00:36:26,194 --> 00:36:29,914
Synagogues are being burned,
community leaders are abused,

351
00:36:29,994 --> 00:36:32,754
sometimes because of
their Jewish appearance,

352
00:36:32,834 --> 00:36:35,674
sometimes because of
being seen as wealthy.

353
00:36:36,034 --> 00:36:39,034
And those things are
happening all over Poland.

354
00:36:40,274 --> 00:36:42,554
This causes a profound shock.

355
00:36:43,394 --> 00:36:46,914
This shatters the
Jewish community at its core

356
00:36:46,994 --> 00:36:48,394
from the very beginning.

357
00:36:53,434 --> 00:36:55,994
Many decrees are being
imposed on the Jews,

358
00:36:56,074 --> 00:36:58,834
and one of the most difficult
one is forced labor.

359
00:37:01,194 --> 00:37:02,754
It meant abducting men.

360
00:37:03,474 --> 00:37:05,514
And these Jewish men who were abducted

361
00:37:05,594 --> 00:37:08,714
might be taken for
work like clearing rubble

362
00:37:08,794 --> 00:37:12,114
from the bombings, or
simply for torture.

363
00:37:12,914 --> 00:37:16,914
They eventually were put into
projects that the SS and the rest of

364
00:37:16,994 --> 00:37:18,714
the Nazi regime had in mind.

365
00:37:20,434 --> 00:37:24,634
One of the recordings echoed
the difficult conditions in the

366
00:37:24,714 --> 00:37:27,514
camps of Skarzyszko-Kamiena
and Szynszuchowa.

367
00:37:28,234 --> 00:37:30,994
In that camp, the Jewish
prisoners were forced to

368
00:37:31,074 --> 00:37:35,274
work with bare hands with this yellow
material that penetrated their skin,

369
00:37:35,354 --> 00:37:38,794
causing them great suffering.
The skin became yellow,

370
00:37:38,874 --> 00:37:41,394
their hair dropped,
their teeth fell out,

371
00:37:41,634 --> 00:37:45,194
and they suffered greatly
until many of them just died.

372
00:37:46,554 --> 00:37:48,994
And many of these men never returned.

373
00:38:23,354 --> 00:38:25,394
And the person who commanded this,

374
00:38:25,634 --> 00:38:27,794
the man in charge,
was Reinhard Heydrich,

375
00:38:28,234 --> 00:38:30,434
one of the senior SS officers.

376
00:38:30,514 --> 00:38:32,754
He's actually one of the
deputies of Heinrich Himmler,

377
00:38:33,074 --> 00:38:34,474
the head of the SS.

378
00:38:34,914 --> 00:38:38,874
And Heydrich, who oversaw
all of these special units

379
00:38:38,954 --> 00:38:41,274
who were brutal and
murderous in Poland,

380
00:38:41,874 --> 00:38:45,114
sent out a schnellbrief,
an express letter

381
00:38:45,194 --> 00:38:46,514
to the commanders of those units

382
00:38:46,594 --> 00:38:48,674
on September the 21st of 1939,

383
00:38:49,354 --> 00:38:52,674
in which he spoke about the final aim,

384
00:38:52,754 --> 00:38:54,554
without saying what that was,

385
00:38:54,634 --> 00:38:58,234
and spelled out the steps on
how to get to the final aim.

386
00:39:01,274 --> 00:39:04,074
More than 3 1/2
million Jews lived in Poland

387
00:39:04,154 --> 00:39:06,874
prior to the war, and
about a third of them,

388
00:39:06,954 --> 00:39:09,074
about a million, were religious Jews.

389
00:39:12,514 --> 00:39:15,314
For the young German
soldier who was raised

390
00:39:15,394 --> 00:39:17,154
within the Nazi education system,

391
00:39:17,354 --> 00:39:19,594
this is actually the very first time

392
00:39:19,674 --> 00:39:21,514
he meets those Polish Jews.

393
00:39:22,354 --> 00:39:24,514
And when those Germans see those Jews,

394
00:39:24,594 --> 00:39:26,154
an eruption of violence follows.

395
00:40:53,794 --> 00:40:57,634
Polish Jews were
ghettoized in the larger cities.

396
00:40:58,394 --> 00:41:02,874
They were systematically
robbed of all of their possessions

397
00:41:02,954 --> 00:41:07,314
and their bank accounts,
anything that could be of value.

398
00:41:07,674 --> 00:41:10,074
But they were also killed at random.

399
00:41:10,434 --> 00:41:13,034
Every now and then,
you'd have a mass shooting

400
00:41:13,114 --> 00:41:14,514
of hundreds of Jews.

401
00:42:13,354 --> 00:42:16,994
Later on, in 1942, as
the operation expanded,

402
00:42:17,354 --> 00:42:20,034
the British realized
that their listeners,

403
00:42:20,594 --> 00:42:24,194
although fluent in German,
are simply not good enough

404
00:42:24,274 --> 00:42:27,314
because they couldn't
grasp the small nuances

405
00:42:27,394 --> 00:42:30,274
and dialect of the
German prisoners of war.

406
00:42:30,354 --> 00:42:35,994
The only way to transcribe with 100%
accuracy was to use native speakers.

407
00:42:39,194 --> 00:42:41,634
The British had such native speakers.

408
00:42:42,674 --> 00:42:48,394
They will use German Jews who
fled Germany in the 1930s

409
00:42:48,474 --> 00:42:50,634
and enlisted to the British Army.

410
00:42:52,594 --> 00:42:58,234
My father turned 18
in the summer of 1940.

411
00:42:59,474 --> 00:43:03,034
And shortly after that, the
British authorities rounded up

412
00:43:03,114 --> 00:43:06,914
all German and Austrian
nationals as enemy aliens.

413
00:43:12,554 --> 00:43:17,874
The only way out of internment was to
volunteer to join the Pioneer Corps.

414
00:43:18,514 --> 00:43:19,674
And this is what he did.

415
00:43:22,674 --> 00:43:26,594
This was when the British
army realized, in the early to

416
00:43:26,674 --> 00:43:29,394
mid 1940s, that they could use

417
00:43:29,474 --> 00:43:34,754
native born German and Austrian
Jews because they could pick

418
00:43:34,834 --> 00:43:39,634
up the details, the nuances of people
speaking their regional dialect.

419
00:43:42,874 --> 00:43:46,674
And the next thing he knew,
he'd signed the Official Secrets Act

420
00:43:46,754 --> 00:43:50,914
and was going to do something for
the war, which he was happy about.

421
00:43:51,874 --> 00:43:56,154
He thought he was going to do
something practical, useful,

422
00:43:56,234 --> 00:43:57,714
get to the front, do something.

423
00:43:58,794 --> 00:44:02,594
In fact he was sent to go and
sit in the basement and listen to

424
00:44:02,674 --> 00:44:06,434
bugged conversations of
captured enemy officers.

425
00:44:11,634 --> 00:44:16,434
So here is my father sitting
in the basement, above him are

426
00:44:16,514 --> 00:44:21,034
people boasting about
their atrocities to each other.

427
00:44:22,034 --> 00:44:26,194
"I killed this many in this place
on this day." "Oh, that's nothing,"

428
00:44:26,274 --> 00:44:28,954
says the other one. "I killed
that many in such a place.

429
00:44:29,034 --> 00:44:30,234
Much more efficient."

430
00:44:30,314 --> 00:44:36,114
These are humans we're talking about.
These are people, and these are Jews.

431
00:44:36,194 --> 00:44:40,194
And here is my father having to
listen to these conversations,

432
00:44:40,274 --> 00:44:43,114
and at the back of
his head all the time is,

433
00:44:43,194 --> 00:44:46,714
"Where are my parents?
Where's my family? Are they safe?"

434
00:44:48,834 --> 00:44:53,554
What he did know was that
he was bearing witness

435
00:44:53,634 --> 00:44:55,674
to what they were
talking about in the hope

436
00:44:55,754 --> 00:44:59,194
that one day they would
have to account for their crimes

437
00:44:59,274 --> 00:45:02,554
and that is what
helped him get through

438
00:45:02,594 --> 00:45:05,274
"I'm listening to this,
I'm recording this

439
00:45:05,354 --> 00:45:08,594
and one day they will have
to answer for their crimes."

440
00:45:11,754 --> 00:45:15,514
It turns out from the
research that women played an

441
00:45:15,594 --> 00:45:19,914
absolutely crucial
part in the recordings.

442
00:45:20,674 --> 00:45:24,514
Women were in some
cases the interrogators,

443
00:45:24,594 --> 00:45:27,914
in other cases they were
analyzing the intelligence

444
00:45:27,994 --> 00:45:29,674
coming out of the M rooms.

445
00:45:29,754 --> 00:45:32,594
These were roles traditionally
not assigned to women

446
00:45:32,674 --> 00:45:35,034
and let alone in wartime.

447
00:45:36,114 --> 00:45:40,514
One of the most extraordinary,
I think, roles that was

448
00:45:40,594 --> 00:45:43,274
undertaken was by Katherine Townshend.

449
00:45:46,194 --> 00:45:52,194
She was young in her early 20s,
she was working on the M room tech,

450
00:45:52,274 --> 00:45:57,434
and from 1942 until the end
of the war and just beyond,

451
00:45:57,474 --> 00:46:01,274
goes on to be head of the
whole of the eavesdropping

452
00:46:01,354 --> 00:46:05,994
technology for British intelligence
in the Second World War.

453
00:46:06,634 --> 00:46:08,154
I find that extraordinary.

454
00:46:11,274 --> 00:46:16,634
My mother wrote a memoir and had it
privately printed for the family.

455
00:46:16,714 --> 00:46:19,154
She said things in the memoir

456
00:46:19,194 --> 00:46:23,114
that she had never spoken
about before because of the

457
00:46:23,194 --> 00:46:25,754
Secrets Act. So the memoir really

458
00:46:25,834 --> 00:46:31,154
was for just the family, and has
not been actually publicly published.

459
00:46:34,514 --> 00:46:37,834
I decided to apply for a
commission with the hope of using my

460
00:46:37,914 --> 00:46:40,714
knowledge of German,
perhaps in intelligence.

461
00:46:43,834 --> 00:46:47,914
Two weeks later, I received
a notice of my acceptance

462
00:46:47,994 --> 00:46:49,434
by military intelligence.

463
00:46:51,594 --> 00:46:57,034
The Combined Services Detailed
Interrogation Center, CSDIC,

464
00:46:57,114 --> 00:46:59,434
was then the only unit of its kind,

465
00:46:59,514 --> 00:47:03,834
but before long there were other
CSDICs elsewhere in England,

466
00:47:03,914 --> 00:47:07,194
and in the Middle East,
India and Australia.

467
00:47:11,194 --> 00:47:15,114
Despite their size, the enemy
never discovered the sites,

468
00:47:15,194 --> 00:47:17,954
or were able to destroy
any of the centers.

469
00:47:21,074 --> 00:47:25,274
With speed and accuracy, my colleagues
transcribed and typed reports

470
00:47:25,354 --> 00:47:27,194
in German and English

471
00:47:27,274 --> 00:47:31,354
for distribution through most
secret channels, sometimes by a

472
00:47:31,434 --> 00:47:34,314
dispatch rider directly
to Churchill himself.

473
00:48:00,114 --> 00:48:03,234
For the British and Americans,
this was not important enough.

474
00:48:04,554 --> 00:48:07,234
Their mantra was, "We'll win the war,

475
00:48:07,314 --> 00:48:08,994
"and this is how we're
going to save the Jews."

476
00:48:13,914 --> 00:48:16,594
The occupation of
Poland is being established,

477
00:48:16,674 --> 00:48:18,834
but at the same time, Nazi Germany

478
00:48:19,234 --> 00:48:21,674
starts setting its
eyes towards the West.

479
00:48:21,754 --> 00:48:25,954
In the first half of 1940, the
attack starts from the north.

480
00:48:26,034 --> 00:48:28,554
First Denmark, then
Belgium and France.

481
00:48:28,954 --> 00:48:34,514
And within weeks, all Western Europe
fell into the hands of Nazi Germany.

482
00:48:40,634 --> 00:48:44,834
Britain remains almost the only
country still fighting Nazi Germany,

483
00:48:45,194 --> 00:48:48,394
despite the fact that it's being
attacked, the blitz, the bombing.

484
00:48:54,074 --> 00:48:56,994
And despite this suffering,
despite the fact that there were a

485
00:48:57,074 --> 00:48:59,194
few attempts to try to convince

486
00:48:59,274 --> 00:49:01,754
Great Britain to sign an
agreement with Nazi Germany,

487
00:49:01,834 --> 00:49:03,234
this doesn't happen.

488
00:49:03,514 --> 00:49:07,234
And Great Britain continues to
be an important force in the

489
00:49:07,314 --> 00:49:08,834
fight against Nazi Germany.

490
00:49:17,434 --> 00:49:20,394
In the first half of 1940,
the situation of Polish Jews

491
00:49:20,474 --> 00:49:22,314
continues to be very difficult.

492
00:49:22,594 --> 00:49:23,874
There are more restrictions.

493
00:49:24,234 --> 00:49:28,634
The hardship is very difficult, and
the food rations are very, very small.

494
00:49:31,914 --> 00:49:34,234
But this is not yet
the final solution.

495
00:49:34,314 --> 00:49:37,154
It is not yet the total
extermination of the Jews.

496
00:49:37,954 --> 00:49:42,274
And in the summer of 1940,
Hitler announced to his service

497
00:49:42,354 --> 00:49:44,074
chiefs that they were going

498
00:49:44,154 --> 00:49:47,194
to attack the Soviet
Union the following year.

499
00:49:50,674 --> 00:49:54,994
The Soviet Union was the
center of the great global

500
00:49:55,074 --> 00:49:58,114
conspiracy of Judeo Bolshevism.

501
00:49:58,194 --> 00:50:00,594
At least this is how Hitler saw it.

502
00:50:03,594 --> 00:50:07,354
And the discourse among these
groups of officials in Germany

503
00:50:07,434 --> 00:50:11,154
became very murderous,
especially regarding Jews.

504
00:50:13,794 --> 00:50:18,234
Hitler tells them, "This
is a war of extermination."

505
00:50:23,634 --> 00:50:27,434
Gradually, more prisoners of
war fell into British hands,

506
00:50:27,514 --> 00:50:28,834
including generals.

507
00:50:30,034 --> 00:50:32,954
These generals commanded
when the Holocaust took place.

508
00:50:34,194 --> 00:50:38,634
The recordings show us not only
how the extermination intensified,

509
00:50:39,274 --> 00:50:41,514
but how it truly became a genocide.


